Getting Smarter with Dissent

1906 – Francis Galton visits a livestock show in England. At a stand, people passing by are allowed to guess how much meat a presented ox would provide after processing. The British researcher rubs his hands delighted: the perfect opportunity to prove statistically that the masses are dumber than an individual and that their estimates are therefore arbitrary. After the show, Galton obtains the 787 cards, on which the estimates are written (after all, there was no data protection back in the days).

Finally at home he calculates - and eureka: the mean value of all estimates only deviates by 0.8% from the actual weight of the ox meat. It is even more accurate than the individual estimates of the butchers and farmers, i. e., experts who should have an eye for it. Galton published his results in Nature and by doing so founded the study of collective intelligence: it refers to the principle that groups of people can be smarter than even the smartest and most experienced individuals among them on their own.

The fine line between bigoted mob and intelligent swarm

Change of scene: 2020 daily project life. 115 years later, I am still confronted with the prevailing opinion on projects that statements from experts are more valuable and more accurate than those of the masses. Especially during transformations and estimations in the Scrum team, participants value the opinions of experts higher than their own and do not dare to take responsibility themselves as a group. However, since Galton's publication, research in various fields has repeatedly shown that the aggregation of many judgments often and sometimes dramatically increases accuracy, since individual errors cancel each other out.

How come so many still believe that crowds are stupid? Well, because they are not infallible. For "swarm intelligence" to work, the following conditions must be met:  

  1. It must be a problem that can be at least roughly evaluated by the individuals: The fair visitors had an idea of how much volume a kilo of meat has. If the questions are too difficult to estimate, the answer of the masses is completely off the mark.
  2. Another crucial condition is that there must be diversity of assessments. If a group is pressured into an answer, follows a hype, or is not allowed to share dissenting opinions, it effectively becomes a single, very fallible individual, well seen in speculative bubbles and the Flat Earthers. It is important that each group member can make independent assessments. The smartest crowds are made up of individuals who disagree with each other.

Collective intelligence also exists outside of estimation

In every transformation, it makes sense to activate the collective knowledge of the employees, because they, in the mass, create a better result than individual experts. Researchers at the University of Washington even managed, with the help of an Internet game and the participation of thousands of non-experts, to decipher the complicated structure of a virus protein (from the monkey virus M-PMV), which molecular biologists and mainframe computers failed to solve.

But even if it's just a meeting on a simpler topic, you should use the power of the group. I noticed the usefulness of this principle in the context of Agile in my very first ScrumMaster training. The trainer used the 1-2-4-All method: After each content block, he asked a question, had each participant first write down an answer by themselves, then discuss it with another person, then in groups of four, and finally with the whole group. I got a lot more sharing and more perspective than in old-fashioned frontal teaching back in my school days. Other favorite methods on my list for unleashing collective intelligence are Triz and Troika Consulting.

Diverse thinking can also be promoted without a group

In an experiment, the two Dutch psychologists Philippe Van de Calseyde and Emir Efendić had people make two estimates. After the first, they were asked to think of a person with whom they often disagreed. This prompted the subjects to adopt a second estimate, which they would not normally have considered as a viable option. The average of these two estimates was generally closer to reality than that of the comparison group. When you make a decision, just think of a family member with whom you often disagree to improve your estimates.

The Scrum team estimates better than the individual

By addressing divergent estimates, the Scrum team members become better. The same applies to opinions in decision-making. "Who can estimate well?" is therefore the wrong question in Scrum, because it is precisely by working together that collective intelligence is activated and thus the group beats every individual. By using swarm intelligence, you ensure that your team is more than the sum of the individuals and produce better results that are closer to the needs of the customers.

Picture: Ariana Prestes, Unsplash

Agile Organization
Leadership
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Estimation
Steffen Bernd
August 31, 2021

Table of content

Diesen Beitrag teilen

Das könnte auch interessant sein:

Agile Coach
Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agile Prinzipien
Agile Toolbox

FRAGE: Warum macht ihr eigentlich kein SAFe?

Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agile Prinzipien
Agile Toolbox
Transformation

FRAGE: Was kostet eine agile Transformation?

Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agile Toolbox
Leadership
Agiles Lernen

FRAGE: Welche Rolle spielt Training?

Agile Coach
Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agile Prinzipien
Agile Toolbox

FRAGE: Wer sind die Top 10 agilen Unternehmensberatungen?

Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agile Tools
Agiles Management
Leadership

FRAGE: Wie viel bringt die Investition? Was ist der Business Case dahinter?

Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agile Prinzipien
Agile Toolbox
Führung

FRAGE: Welche sind häufige Herausforderungen, die ihr beim Kunden löst?

Agile Management
Agile Organization

FRAGE: Warum sollten wir mit borisgloger arbeiten?

Agile Management
Agile Organization
Agiles Management
Transformation

FRAGE: Wie viel kostet eine Beratung und ist es wirklich rentabel bei borisgloger?

Agile Prinzipien
Agile Toolbox
Projektmanagement

The Lie Behind the Parable of the Golf Balls and the Jar

Video
Change
Digitale Transformation
Hardware
Agile Organization

Agile in Industrial Automation: The Digital Transformation of Yokogawa

Versicherung
Neues Arbeiten
Führung
Agile Prinzipien
Kundenfokus

Kundenzentrierte Versicherung: Kann ein agiles Projekt die Organisation retten?

Versicherung
Change
Digitale Transformation
Agile Prinzipien
Kundenfokus

Agilität in den Vertrieb bringen – für Versicherer sinnvoll

Versicherung
Agile Prinzipien
Kundenfokus
Agile Toolbox
Produktentwicklung

BizDevOps in der Versicherungsbranche – Wie multidisziplinäre Teams wirklich besetzt sein sollten

Versicherung
Agile Prinzipien
Kundenfokus
Neues Arbeiten
Meetings

Undercover Agile für Versicherer: 5 agile Praktiken für Ihr klassisches IT-Projekt

Versicherung
Change
Digitale Transformation
Agile Prinzipien
Kundenfokus

IT-Projekte in der Versicherungsbranche – Das Rennen um die Time-to-Market

Team
Neues Arbeiten
Agile Prinzipien
Selbstorganisation
Social Skills

Umgang mit Fehlern & Diversität – Erfolgreiche agile Teams #2

Team
Neues Arbeiten
Agile Toolbox
Produktentwicklung

Das Geheimrezept von High-Performance-Teams

Team
Arbeiten bei borisgloger consulting
Agile Prinzipien
Freiwilligkeit
Selbstorganisation

Konsent und offene Wahl: 2 Prinzipien aus der Soziokratie, die jedes agile Team gebrauchen kann

Team
Neues Arbeiten
Meetings
Social Skills

Der agile Adventkalender

Team
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
ScrumMaster-Praxistipps
Agile Prinzipien

Selbstorganisation der Teams fördern: Ask the team!

Team
Agile Toolbox
Design Thinking

Who Recognizes the Truly Good Ideas?

Team
Agile Organization
Transformation

Pizza Is Not Dead, and Neither Is Agility

Scrum4Schools
Neues Arbeiten
Führung
Life
Social Skills

Trauen wir unseren Kindern mehr zu – auch in der Schule!

Scrum4Schools
Change
Agiles Lernen
Neues Arbeiten
Remote Arbeiten

Eine Scrum4Schools-Projekt-Rückschau mit Physiklehrer Ivan Topic

Scrum4Schools
Mehr Formate
Interview
Nachhaltigkeit

Mit Scrum4Schools dem Weltraum auf der Spur

Scrum4Schools
Change
Agiles Lernen

Scrum4Schools - ein Projekt nimmt Fahrt auf

Scrum4Schools
Agile Schulentwicklung
Agile Toolbox

Technik im Alltag - Scrum4Schools zu Gast in Langenzersdorf

Projektmanagement
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Scrum-Begriffe
ScrumMaster-Praxistipps

Sprechen Sie Agile? Den klassischen Projektplan in die agile Welt überführen

Projektmanagement
Agiles Management
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Enterprise Scrum

Das Management in Scrum

Projektmanagement
Change
Digitale Transformation

Agilität in der Logistik oder: Liefern wie Amazon

Projektmanagement
Agile Toolbox
Scrum

Meilensteine und Scrum

Portfoliomanagement
Project management

Too many projects? Portfolio management simplified

Neues Arbeiten
Mehr Formate
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Scrum Values

Wie agiles Arbeiten die Kommunikation aus der Selbstverständlichkeit holt

Neues Arbeiten
Change
Agiles Lernen
Mehr Formate
Audio

New Learning heute für das New Work von morgen – mit Angelika Weis

Neues Arbeiten
Change
Soziale Innovation

New Work Experience 2019 – ein Erfahrungsbericht

Neues Arbeiten
Audit
Change

Agil im Audit: das Starter-Kit

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Scrum4Schools
Agile Prinzipien

Scrum4Schools: Lernen für die Zukunft

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Scrum Meetings
Retrospektive

Arbeiten wir uns gesund!

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
ScrumMaster-Praxistipps

Who should be in (agile) HR?

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Scrum Values

Glauben Sie an die Seele Ihrer Firma?

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Toolbox
Scrum
Product Owner
ScrumMaster-Praxistipps

Produktivität auf Irrwegen: "Führen wir schnell mal Scrum ein!"

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Prinzipien
Selbstorganisation
Social Skills
Team

Freiwilliges Teilen von Wissen – Erfolgreiche agile Teams #5

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Prinzipien
Selbstorganisation
Social Skills
Team

Doing vs. Being Agile – Erfolgreiche agile Teams #1

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Prinzipien
Selbstorganisation
Social Skills
Team

Freude bei der Arbeit & Sustainable Pace – Erfolgreiche agile Teams #3

Neues Arbeiten
Agile Prinzipien
Selbstorganisation
Social Skills
Team

Anpassungsfähigkeit & schonungslose Offenheit – Erfolgreiche agile Teams #4